Ex-Chiefs
| Joseph Szabo | 1913-15 | Frank Partyka | 1977 |
| John Hacker | 1916-19 | Patrick Agugliaro | 1978 |
| Joseph Utassy | 1920-21 | Robert Kazimir | 1979 |
| Florian Wranitz | 1922-23 | Edward J. Berardi | 1980 |
| Louis Kromer | 1924 | Andrew Abaray | 1981 |
| Henry Luskie | 1925 | William H. Balog | 1982 |
| Fred Leidner | 1926 | Paul J. Dunda | 1983 |
| Anthony Galaida | 1927 | Dennis M. Derewsky | 1984 |
| George Fox | 1928 | Frank J. Boyle | 1985 |
| Caril Neir | 1929 | Steve Terebetsky | 1986 |
| John Larson | 1930 | Earl A. Runkel III | 1987 |
| Otto Toepfer | 1931 | Andrew Mazzarella | 1988 |
| Paul Solomon | 1932 | Gary Driscoll | 1989 |
| Charles Mezera | 1933 | Phillip Kerchner | 1990 |
| Charles Flynn | 1934 | Walter E. Hanks | 1991 |
| John Tjornelund | 1935 | Frank J. Boyle | 1992 |
| Harold Hanson | 1936 | John M. Mitch | 1993 |
| George Hackett | 1937 | Earl A. Runkel III | 1994 |
| William Kuzmiak | 1938 | Bruce M. Mizak | 1995 |
| Edward Kennedy | 1939 | William J. Gotto | 1996 |
| Jacob Herman | 1940 | Dean C. Manente | 1997 |
| George Ruff | 1941 | Walter E. Hanks | 1998 |
| Michael Petras | 1942 | David S. Eidson | 1999 |
| Hiram Tuttle | 1944 | Walter E. Hanks | 2000 |
| William Russell | 1944 | William F. Moran | 2001 |
| Albert Ramon | 1945 | John G. Letso Jr. | 2002 |
| Harold Deter | 1946 | Keith W. Addie | 2003 |
| George Slivka | 1947 | Frank Strain | 2004 |
| John Anacker | 1948 | Jerry Sternesky | 2005 |
| George Kovack | 1949 | Cory S. Spillar | 2006 |
| Andrew Galisin | 1950 | Frank Strain | 2007 |
| John Lockie | 1951 | Bruce M. Mizak | 2008-09 |
| Michael Florio | 1952 | Christopher S. Neroda | 2010 |
| Rubin Greco | 1953 | Daniel M. Mizak | 2011 |
| Herman Steinbach | 1954 | Frank Strain | 2012 |
| Andrew Peterson | 1955 | James Karlbon | 2013 |
| Jacob Essig | 1956 | Daniel M. Mizak | 2014 |
| John Tomas | 1957 | Frank D. Boyle | 2015 |
| Wallace Melville | 1958 | Jerry Sternesky | 2016 |
| William Dwyer | 1959 | Frank D. Boyle | 2017 |
| Stanley Derewsky | 1960 | Michael Hamilton | 2018 |
| Herman Petz | 1961 | Daniel M. Mizak | 2019 |
| Lonnie V. Eidson Sr. | 1962 | Ayman Elbayar | 2020-21 |
| Paul Chomiak | 1963 | Frank Strain | 2022 |
| Steve Cohorsky | 1964 | James Boelhower | 2023 |
| George Shaffer | 1965 | ||
| Walter Sobieski | 1966 | ||
| Raymond Hoppock | 1967 | ||
| Joseph Placca | 1968 | ||
| Robert J. Cuna | 1969 | ||
| Walter S. Hanks | 1970 | ||
| George Ludwig | 1971-72 | ||
| Joel F. Roberts | 1973 | ||
| Peter F. Connell | 1974 | ||
| Joseph E. O'Donnell | 1975 | ||
| Charles Holovacko Jr. | 1976 |